SimilarBooks.org
Cover of White Christmas pie

Books like this one

Books like White Christmas pie

5.0 (1 community ratings)

Set against the tranquil backdrop of Amish life, "White Christmas Pie" follows Will Henderson, a man wrestling with his history, as he meets Karen Yoder, a woman on a quest for meaning. Their budding relationship is tested by a nearby family crisis—a father desperate to find his lost son. The novel weaves themes of love, forgiveness, and community within a tradition‑rich setting, offering readers a bittersweet holiday narrative that balances romance with heartfelt family drama.

Romance Contemporary Romance First published: 2008

Discover your next read

Books similar to White Christmas pie

Compare books other readers have recommended. Vote to help improve these suggestions.

15 books

Looking for more books like White Christmas pie by Wanda E. Brunstetter? This list brings together suggested alternatives and feedback from SimilarBooks readers. Ratings reflect what readers think of each individual book, while the Yes and No votes show whether visitors consider it a good match for this title. Compare the recommendations below and suggest another book to help fellow readers discover their next read.

Cover of The shepherd's bride

The shepherd's bride

Patricia Davids

5.0 (2)

A shunned Amish shepherd meets a woman seeking a new start; their growing bond challenges community boundaries and offers hope for redemption.

Is this book similar?
Cover of Becoming Bea

Becoming Bea

Gould, Leslie

4.5 (2)

Ben and Bea, who have always been at odds, may finally let their bickering give way to romance when friends bring them together.

Is this book similar?
Cover of The Secret Keeper

The Secret Keeper

Beverly Lewis

5.0 (2)

Jennifer Burns discovers that stepping into the Amish community of Pennsylvania will test her faith, her family, and her own sense of belonging i...

Is this book similar?
Cover of Amish Christmas joy

Amish Christmas joy

Patricia Davids

5.0 (1)

Caleb, a rugged oil‐rig worker, discovers he has an eight‑year‑old special‑needs daughter, Joy.

Is this book similar?
Cover of Plain admirer

Plain admirer

Patricia Davids

5.0 (1)

Joann Yoder, an Amish woman content with her single life, faces a career setback when she is fired for a younger man.

Is this book similar?
Cover of Amish Promises

Amish Promises

Leslie Gould

5.0 (1)

Neighbors from different worlds find conflict, friendship, and love in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, as an English family and an Amish household inter...

Is this book similar?
Cover of A Home For Hannah

A Home For Hannah

Patricia Davids

Nurse Miriam Kaufman leaves her Amish roots, returning to Ohio to care for her mother while helping Sheriff Nick Bradley locate a baby, Hannah, a...

Is this book similar?
Cover of The Atonement

The Atonement

Beverly Lewis

A woman haunted by past mistakes struggles with faith and love in a small Amish community, exploring redemption and the possibility of new beginn...

Is this book similar?

Subjects and themes

Fiction, Large type books, Abandoned children, Couples, Amish

How our recommendations work

Community ratings describe each book independently. Similarity votes measure whether readers consider a recommendation a good match for this particular title; results can change as more visitors share feedback.

Have a recommendation?

Suggest another book below, or vote Yes or No on any existing recommendation.

Share your suggestion →

More related books

The Amish Virgin by Kelly Irvin
Candle on the Waters by Connie Quackenbush
The Blessings of All Who Come by Maggie Miller
An Amish Christmas by Kelly Irvin
Seasons of Tangles by Shelley Shepherd Gray
The Choosing by Ruth Reid
A Christmas Song by Ruth Reid
The Hope Jar by NONE
The Innkeeper's Daughter by Jenna Blum

Readers make discovery better

Know a similar book?

Share a recommendation and help other readers discover their next great read.

Please sign in to suggest a book.