The Confession
After being shunned from her Amish community, Katie Lapp confronts a new life in English America while her love plans a return to her Amish roots...

Books like this one
In the tranquil Amish community of Naomi Fisher, time feels still. After her widowed father’s shop, Naomi helps run a household, care for seven children, and keep a quiet life together. Though her heart longs for Caleb Hoffmeir, her days are fixed by the demands of family. The calm is broken when Naomi’s baby brother disappears from the yard, pulling her into a desperate search for answers amid familiar rituals and hidden tensions. A story of faith, duty, and the bonds that hold a family—and community—together.
Discover your next read
Compare books other readers have recommended. Vote to help improve these suggestions.
Looking for more books like The storekeeper's daughter by Wanda E. Brunstetter? This list brings together suggested alternatives and feedback from SimilarBooks readers. Ratings reflect what readers think of each individual book, while the Yes and No votes show whether visitors consider it a good match for this title. Compare the recommendations below and suggest another book to help fellow readers discover their next read.
After being shunned from her Amish community, Katie Lapp confronts a new life in English America while her love plans a return to her Amish roots...
A shunned Amish shepherd meets a woman seeking a new start; their growing bond challenges community boundaries and offers hope for redemption.
Ben and Bea, who have always been at odds, may finally let their bickering give way to romance when friends bring them together.
After her wedding, Katie Lapp must blend her Plain Amish heritage with her new life as the steward of Mayfield Manor, balancing charity at a hosp...
In the post‑World War II Amish community of Gobbler’s Knob, two sisters confront tradition, desire, and a secret pact that could change their liv...
Amish widow Rachel Yoder runs a bed‑and‑breakfast in Lancaster when a New York journalist, Philip Bradley, discovers an old postcard that draws h...
Caleb, a rugged oil‐rig worker, discovers he has an eight‑year‑old special‑needs daughter, Joy.
Neighbors from different worlds find conflict, friendship, and love in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, as an English family and an Amish household inter...
Wanda E.
Widowed Sarah Turner balances family, canal duties, and a devotion to her heart as she confronts love offers from a sea-faring captain and a land...
A woman haunted by past mistakes struggles with faith and love in a small Amish community, exploring redemption and the possibility of new beginn...
A faith‑driven story of family and love set in historic Kansas.
Tilly and Ruth, formerly Amish sisters, confront lingering hurt when they return to their home county for their parents’ wedding anniversary, nav...
Annie Zook, the preacher's daughter, vows to give up her art for six months to honor her father.
Nellie Fisher, grieving her sister’s death, faces the challenge of loving Caleb Yoder, whom her father forbids her to court, while navigating the...
During Christmas, Emma Swartzentruber faces family crisis and discovers love in the returning Luke Bowman, who must prove himself worthy of the A...
Fiction, Fathers and daughters, Large type books, Christian fiction, Amish
Community ratings describe each book independently. Similarity votes measure whether readers consider a recommendation a good match for this particular title; results can change as more visitors share feedback.
Suggest another book below, or vote Yes or No on any existing recommendation.
Share your suggestion →Readers make discovery better
Share a recommendation and help other readers discover their next great read.